Skip to content
2024 Criminal TrialtranscripttranscriptJohn Alden — Direct/Cross - Day 8 - 2024 Criminal TrialDefense witness John Alden described observations during an August 2019 battery call and confirmed Jorge Torres's arrest. Cross-examination addressed his recollection and the basis for the investigation.
William R. JayKevin Timothy BeckTony HendersonJames Sylivan OwensMichael KraynickJohn AldenTHE COURTMR. HENDERSONJohn AldenCourt ClerkMR. JAYMR. BECKMR. OWENSdirectcrosssidebar
2024 Criminal Trial/Day 8/October 23, 2024
9 pages·7 witnesses·2,536 lines
Defense witnesses described earlier injuries and police responses, while Michael Brannon explained battered spouse syndrome generally and Julie Harper offered assessment opinions about Boone. Cross-examination addressed Harper's methods and Boone's suitcase account. Phone videos were published, and no-contact orders were premarked but not admitted.
DirectDirectJohn Alden — Direct John Alden Tony Henderson
126:02

THE COURT: Defense, call your next witness.

226:04

MR. HENDERSON: At this time, the defense calls Deputy John Alden.

JOHN ALDEN

being called as a witness, and having first been duly sworn,

testified as follows:

COURT CLERK: Thank you.

826:46

THE COURT: Sir, good morning. Can you state and spell your name for the record?

926:50

JOHN ALDEN: John Alden, J-o-h-n A-1-d-e-n.

1026:54

THE COURT: All right. Thank you, sir. You may be seated.

Mr. Henderson, you may inquire.

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. HENDERSON:

1326:57

MR. HENDERSON: Good morning, sir.

1426:58

JOHN ALDEN: Good morning.

1527:00

MR. HENDERSON: Sir, how are you employed? How are you employed?

1627:04

JOHN ALDEN: I'm employed with the Orange County Sheriff's Office as a corporal.

1727:07

MR. HENDERSON: Okay. Back on August the 28th of 2019, how were you employed?

1827:12

JOHN ALDEN: I was a deputy in uniform patrol division in Sector 2.

1927:16

MR. HENDERSON: Okay. As a part of your job duties that day, did you have the occasion to respond to 4748 Frantz Lane, No. 3?

2027:26
2127:26

MR. HENDERSON: What was the purpose?

2227:29

JOHN ALDEN: There ended up being a battery call.

2327:32

MR. HENDERSON: Okay. And, sir, were you the lead officer on this case?

2427:37
2527:38

MR. HENDERSON: Were there any other backup officers there with you?

2627:42

JOHN ALDEN: I believe so.

2727:44

MR. HENDERSON: Okay. Sir, on that date, August the 28th of 2019, did you come in contact with Sarah Boone?

2827:52
2927:52

MR. HENDERSON: Okay. Sir, on that date, did you observe any injuries on Sarah Boone?

3028:00

JOHN ALDEN: I observed redness on the left side of her neck and looked to be an old injury to her right eye.

3128:05

MR. HENDERSON: Sir, on August 28th of 2019, did you come in contact with Jorge Torres?

3228:19
3328:20

MR. HENDERSON: And did you notice any injuries on Mr. Torres?

3428:24

JOHN ALDEN: Yes. He had some redness by his left eye.

3528:33

MR. HENDERSON: Sir, on that day, was Mr. Torres placed under arrest?

3628:37
3728:39

MR. HENDERSON: Thank you. I have no further questions.

3828:42

THE COURT: Any cross-examination?

3928:44
CrossCrossJohn Alden — Cross John Alden William R. Jay

CROSS-EXAMINATION

BY MR. JAY:

4228:45

MR. JAY: Is it fair to say that Mr. Torres had quite a few marks on him?

4328:49

JOHN ALDEN: From my report, I remember marking the left -- light redness by his left eye.

4428:55

MR. JAY: And did you have your body-worn camera activated when you responded to this call?

4528:59

JOHN ALDEN: I believe so.

4629:00

MR. JAY: All right. And so that would be the best evidence of both video and audio as to what occurred while you were on scene?

4729:08

JOHN ALDEN: It would, especially since this happened four years -- well, five years ago now.

4829:11

MR. JAY: And did Mr. Torres refuse to say what happened that day?

4929:16

JOHN ALDEN: He did.

5029:16

MR. JAY: Based on the conclusion of your investigation, which involved talking to Ms. Boone and attempting to talk to Mr. Torres, as well as your visual observations of both of them in the scene, is that how you-all reach your conclusions?

5129:31
5229:31

MR. JAY: No other questions.

5329:33

THE COURT: Any redirect?

5429:34

MR. HENDERSON: No, Your Honor.

5529:35

THE COURT: Can this witness be released?

5629:36

MR. HENDERSON: Yes, Your Honor.

5729:37

THE COURT: Mr. Jay?

5829:38

MR. JAY: Yes, sir.

5929:39

THE COURT: Thank you, sir.

6029:39

JOHN ALDEN: Thank you.

(Witness excused.)

6229:40

THE COURT: Defense, you can call your next witness.

MR. HENDERSON: Judge, may we approach?

sidebarsidebarWitness Order While Awaiting Dr. Brannon

(At the bench.)

THE COURT: Yes, sir?

MR. HENDERSON: Judge, Dr. Brannon was supposed to be our next witness. Mr. Beck informs me that he's not here yet.

Have you had contact with him?

MR. BECK: I have. I've contacted him via text this morning. He indicated that he is going to be arriving at the courthouse around 9:30.

THE COURT: Okay. Do you have another witness that we might be able to fill the bridge?

MR. HENDERSON: I'm trying.

MR. JAY: Scott Lowen is here.

THE COURT: Detective Lowen is here?

MR. OWENS: The detectives are here.

THE COURT: Can we do that?

MR. HENDERSON: I'11 do that.

THE COURT: Appreciate it. Thank you.

Continue to next page3.Chelsey Koepsell — Direct (Recall)